wd green, blue, red, or black (2tb)?

[paranoid.asian]

ohai,

mam moznost kupit wd green 2tb za 60e
cena je viac nez priazniva, ale nemam skusenosti so ziadnym green (len 3tb red).

nejake info by som potreboval, ci sa to oplati, kupit alebo radsej si najst vyssiu radu?

dak.

[stiv]

Vezmi Black, co budes kupovat pomale disky.

[paranoid.asian]

aj to je riesenie
ale skor potrebujem zistit, ci sa green oplati neoplati z hladiska kvality, vydrze.
viem ze black su rychlejsie, ale i drahsie.
nie je to pre mna, tak preto zistujem co sa da, kde sa da.
byt na mne, kupujem black/red.

+ pridavam vyuzitie.
bude to ulozisko (fotiek, filmov, mp3, etc)
cize nic, co by vyzadovalo rychlu dostupnost.

[shiro]

Ked len ulozisko, tak neni o com ber green.
Pri 1TB+ diskoch maju vsetky citanie/zapis okolo 100MB/s a viac.

Black disky su rychle, ale viacej sa kvoli tomu hreju a su predrazene. predsalen 1TB WD Blue mas za 100e a Black za 160? akoze wtf? Kedysi tam nebol tak vyrazny cenovy rozdiel, WD by si zasluzilo asi prefackat. nech sa vratia do reality. Napr. rozdiel medzi 2.5" 750GB Blue vs Black je zo 20e. Takze co sa deje u 3.5" HDD?

[Alien2008]

Ja by som bral namiesto Green radšej RED, vyššia spoľahlivosť a záruka 3 roky.

[paranoid.asian]

tie green disky nie su nove, bez zaruky.
vypis zo smartu

Drive Model: WDC WD20EARS-00MVWB0
Drive Revision: 51.0AB51

[01] Raw Read Error Rate: 200/51, Worst: 200 (Data = 2) 200/51, Worst: 200
[03] Spin Up Time: 222/21, Worst: 167 (Data = 3891) 221/21, Worst: 164 (Data = 3908)
[04] Start/Stop Count: 98/Always OK, Worst: 98 (Data = 2639) 98/Always OK, Worst: 98 (Data = 2567)
[05] Reallocated Sector Count: 200/140, Worst: 200 200/140, Worst: 200
[07] Seek Error Rate: 100/Always OK, Worst: 253 200/Always OK, Worst: 200
[09] Power-On Hours/Cycle Count: 80/Always OK, Worst: 80 (Data = 14787 hours / 1.69 years) 80/Always OK, Worst: 80 (Data = 14825 hours / 1.69 years)
[0A] Spin Retry Count: 100/Always OK, Worst: 100 100/Always OK, Worst: 100
[0B] Calibration Retry Count: 100/Always OK, Worst: 100 100/Always OK, Worst: 100
[0C] Power Cycle Count: 99/Always OK, Worst: 99 (Data = 1585) 99/Always OK, Worst: 99 (Data = 1593)
[C0] Power-Off Retract Count: 200/Always OK, Worst: 200 (Data = 181) 200/Always OK, Worst: 200 (Data = 182)
[C1] Load/Unload Cycle Count: 161/Always OK, Worst: 161 (Data = 117391) 144/Always OK, Worst: 144 (Data = 168096)
[C2] Temperature 115/Always OK, Worst: 104 (Data = 35.0 °C) 114/Always OK, Worst: 104 (Data = 36.0 °C)
[C4] Reallocation Event Count: 200/Always OK, Worst: 200 200/Always OK, Worst: 200
[C5] Current Pending Sector Count: 200/Always OK, Worst: 200 200/Always OK, Worst: 200
[C6] Off-Line Uncorrectable Sector Count: 200/Always OK, Worst: 200 200/Always OK, Worst: 200
[C7] UltraDMA/SATA CRC Error Rate: 200/Always OK, Worst: 200 200/Always OK, Worst: 200
[C8] Write/Multi-Zone Error Rate: 200/Always OK, Worst: 200 200/Always OK, Worst: 200

[stiv]

1TB WD Blue mas za 100e a Black za 160?

Isto nie.

Ja by som aj tak stare greeny bez zaruky nebral. Ak teda netreba disk za co najmensiu cenu.

[shiro]

S cenami som riadne mimo, pravda
Tak oprava. Ceny z alzy, pri 3TB nemaju black verziu, tak sem davam kapacity pri ktorych ju maju. Na predstavu ake su cenove rozdiely. Blue je v mnohych pripadoch lacnejsi nez green a je to skoro to iste.
1TB wd blue 56e, black je za 87.
2TB blue 83e, black 146e
4TB blue 172e, black 249e

Co sa tyka pouzitych hdd bez zaruky - jasne ze nebrat, brat vzdy len nove so zarukou. Ak to neplanujes pouzivat na nedolezite data, kde nevadi ze disk umre a jedneho dna nenabehne.